Bible LockDownloadBIBLE LOCK GUIDES
How to Stop Overthinking Everything
I think this might be one of the most relatable articles I've written so far, because I'm an overthinker myself. And if you're one too, you probably know exactly how exhausting it can be...
You send a message to a friend. They read it but don't reply. At first, you don't think much of it. Then an hour passes, and you start wondering if you said something wrong. You reread your message, check when they were last online, and come up with several explanations for why they haven't answered. By the end of the day, you've spent hours thinking about a situation that might not mean anything at all.
That's the frustrating thing about overthinking. A small moment can take up so much space in your head that it becomes difficult to focus on anything else. And telling yourself to “just stop thinking about it” rarely works. The harder you try to force a thought away, the more attention you can end up giving it.
So instead of trying to switch your brain off, let's look at a few ways to break the cycle and stop giving every thought so much power.
1. Separate What Actually Happened From the Story You're Telling Yourself
One reason we overthink is that we often treat our assumptions as if they're facts. Someone replies with a short message, and we assume they're annoyed. Our boss asks to talk tomorrow, and we immediately worry that we've done something wrong. We make a mistake and convince ourselves that everyone noticed.
But look at what actually happened in each situation. The person sent a short reply. Your boss asked to talk. You made a mistake. Everything else is an interpretation. The next time you catch yourself spiraling, try writing down two things:
- What I know: The actual facts of the situation.
- What I'm assuming: The meaning or outcome I'm imagining.
For example:
What I know: My friend hasn't replied to my message.
What I'm assuming: She's upset with me and doesn't want to talk anymore.
There may be a reason for the silence, but you don't know what it is yet. She could be busy, tired, or simply unable to reply. This exercise won't give you an immediate answer, but it can help you stop treating your worst assumption as the only possible explanation.
2. Give Yourself a Limit for Making Decisions
Sometimes, overthinking happens because we want to make the perfect decision. We compare every option, look for more information, ask several people for advice, and keep reconsidering even after we've made a choice.
This can happen with big decisions, like choosing a job, but also with small ones, like deciding what to buy or what to eat. The problem is that more thinking doesn't always lead to a better decision. At some point, it just makes choosing harder. Try setting a reasonable time limit based on the decision.
For something small, give yourself a few minutes. For something important, take more time, gather the information you genuinely need, and think about the consequences. Then make the best decision you can with what you know.
You can always adjust your approach when you learn something new. You don't need to predict every possible outcome before you're allowed to choose.
3. Stop Reopening a Problem You've Already Dealt With
Imagine you've had an uncomfortable conversation. You apologized for your part, explained what you meant, and did what you could to make things right. But later that night, you start replaying the conversation again. Maybe you should have worded something differently. Maybe the other person misunderstood you. Maybe there's something else you should say. Before long, you're back where you started.
When this happens, ask yourself one question: Is there new information that requires me to do something, or am I reviewing the same situation again? If there's something you genuinely need to address, make a plan to address it. But if you've already done what you can and nothing new has happened, you don't need to keep putting yourself through the same mental review. You can acknowledge that the situation wasn't perfect and still allow yourself to move on.
4. Get the Thoughts Out of Your Head
When several worries compete for your attention, they can start to feel bigger and more confusing than they really are. One practical way to deal with this is to write everything down.
Take a notebook or open a blank document and write out whatever is on your mind. Don't worry about making it neat or finding solutions immediately. Just get the thoughts out. Then look at what you've written and sort each concern into one of three groups:
- Something I can act on: Write down one specific next step.
- Something I need more information about: Decide when or how you can get that information.
- Something I can't resolve right now: Acknowledge it, and stop treating it like an urgent task.
This approach turns a vague cloud of worry into something more manageable. You may not be able to resolve everything, but you can usually identify what needs your attention first.
5. Give Your Attention Something Else to Do
Have you ever noticed that your thoughts get louder when you're lying in bed, sitting around with nothing to do, or scrolling on your phone? Sometimes, trying to think your way out of overthinking only keeps you stuck in it.
Instead, try moving your attention to something that requires you to engage with the present. Take a walk without checking your phone, cook something, tidy a small part of your room, or have a conversation with someone you trust.
The point isn't to stay busy every second so you never have to think about your problems. It's to remind yourself that you can have a thought without spending the next hour following it.
6. Use Prayer to Change How You Respond to Your Thoughts
As Christians, we can also bring this struggle into our relationship with God. But that doesn't mean every worrying thought will disappear the moment we pray. Sometimes, prayer is less about getting an immediate answer and more about being honest with God about what's going on in our minds.
Philippians 4:8 encourages us to direct our thoughts toward things that are true, honorable, just, pure, lovely, and worthy of praise.
This gives us something practical to reflect on when we're caught in a negative thought loop. Ask yourself: Is this thought based on something I know to be true? Is thinking about it helping me respond wisely? Or am I repeatedly imagining something that might never happen?
You could also take a few minutes to pray or read a short passage of Scripture when you notice yourself spiraling. Not as a way to force every uncomfortable feeling away, but as a chance to pause, reflect, and reconnect with what matters to you.
If you find yourself reaching for social media every time your thoughts get uncomfortable, putting your phone aside for a few minutes may help you create that space. Bible Lock can also help you build a simple Scripture habit by placing Bible verses on your lock screen and blocking distracting apps until you've read them. Take a Moment With Scripture →
What If You Start Overthinking Again?
Well... As sucks as it sounds, you probably will. That's not a reason to feel frustrated with yourself. The goal isn't to reach a point where you never overthink anything. It's to recognize the pattern sooner and learn not to follow every thought to its conclusion. The next time you catch yourself going over the same situation for the tenth time, try this:
Pause. Check the facts. Decide whether there's anything you need to do. Then return to what you're doing.